Trevor S. Palmer, Managing Director at Sontay, examines the role that room sensors have played in the rise of the building control system and looks at the impact of current trends on the design and development of these devices now and in the years to come.
Building Management Systems (BMS) have been a major success story in UK commercial buildings over the last 25 years. They combine energy saving control techniques, such as optimum start and dead bands, with communication and information systems that allow active management of the building services and the capability to achieve and maintain a high level of energy efficiency and lower carbon emissions.
For all the sophistication, advanced feature-sets and benefits that these control systems bring to their occupants, they are dependant for their success upon the humble sensor.
Room temperature and humidity sensing and transmitting products began in conjunction with the development and proliferation of centralised building management systems in the 1980’s. Traditionally, the manufacture of these two-wire products was limited to the major systems manufacturers of the day – companies like Honeywell, Johnson Controls and Barber Coleman (today owned by Schneider Electric).
Right from their original introduction as the eyes and ears of the BMS, misconceptions have persisted in terms of how accurate these devices really need to be, how fast they should react and what precisely constitutes a high quality room and/or duct sensor. These factors are important and they demand closer consideration from consultants, contractors and systems integrators charged with delivering energy efficient control systems for today’s buildings.
As an example, many consulting engineers continue to specify 0-10V transmitters equipped with PT100 type temperature elements, as standard. The commonly held view is that these products are more accurate than box-standard thermistors. In fact, quite the opposite is true. Thermistors are today available in different grades and types which quite often exceed the accuracy of transmitters of old.
Measurement accuracy versus stability is another talking point. Generally speaking, the industry has relied and continues to rely on temperature sensors which are low cost and tolerate +/- 0.3°C over the entire range (-10 to +70). As a result, this has become the specification standard within the UK market. But what is really important from a sensing perspective is longer term stability rather than absolute accuracy. It is much more important for devices to remain accurate within the manufacturer’s specification (+/-0.3°C) for the life of the device than their absolute accuracy. After all, these devices are being applied within commercial buildings to enhance occupant comfort and improve energy savings over the long term. If our balance of priorities shifts in favour of performance stability over absolute accuracy then these benefits can be successfully realised.
Risk of compromise
Sensor cost also remains an issue. Accounting for just 2% of the budget for a whole project, room sensors themselves are not always the main focus of attention when it comes to selecting and specifying the building control system. However, different price-points often reflect a differential in quality. Choosing the lowest cost sensor brings with it the increased risk of compromising on long-term measurement reliability and performance stability. Device failure can lead to the time and cost of unnecessary call out and product replacement issues, alongside the unwanted cost of reputational damage to the specifying contractor and consultant.
Increasingly popular wireless sensor technology is also having a fundamental impact in transforming how we think about the cost of sensor installation. By eliminating the need for structural cabling during sensor installation, wireless devices can greatly reduce engineering time and installed project cost. This enables faster and easier installation on new buildings and also opens up the opportunity for control specialists to retrofit energy efficient HVAC controls into existing commercial and public buildings. In projects which feature our SonNet family of wireless sensors, we are typically finding total installed cost savings of 30% and more over comparable wired sensor installations. At a time when reducing costs are a priority on many projects, proven wireless technology can bring significant benefit.
Seamless integration of wireless technology is essential and making sensors compatible with current building control systems aids this process. We have introduced the Tridium NiagaraAX driver to our SonNet network radio receivers to enable quick and seamless integration with Tridium’s range of JACE controllers as part of a NiagaraAX framework for building control systems. This opens up the system to BMS protocols such as BACnet, LonTalk and Modbus. The new driver ensures Sontay’s RF-RXS receivers serve up a Tridium compatible web interface where SonNet wireless sensors are used on a project. This allows engineers to gather measurement data from the sensors and also perform radio network management services, such as, auto-commissioning and setting device configuration parameters as part of a building’s Tridium NiagaraAX framework.
Today, changing aesthetics and increased functionality are also important drivers in helping us re-evaluate the way that we look at sensors.
Up until now, sensors located in the space have been selected with little or no regard to design aesthetics. The latest devices available on the market offer an opportunity for specifiers not simply to satisfy the functional demands of their client but also the impact of the sensor on the interior space, and the look and feel of these devices. Take our new range of TT-1000 space temperature sensors. These room sensors feature a specially designed low profile and curved fascia to ensure that they can blend stylishly and seamlessly into a room’s design scheme whilst still helping to deliver greater energy efficiency, cost savings and carbon reductions in new build and retrofit building applications. The bland and, frankly, cheap-looking design of the ordinary room sensor need no longer be a barrier nor an unwanted intrusion into the design scheme of the upmarket commercial office building.
At the same time, the longer term trend is away from single use sensors, one for temperature and one for humidity, to single, multi-functional environmental sensors. These modern devices, such as our GS-CO2-AQ-RHT, can measure different important variables within the overall space conditions which may include air quality, CO2 for occupancy alongside traditional temperature and humidity measurements.
This combined approach offers numerous advantages to the systems integrator and the client. The building owner enjoys the ability to monitor and report on total environmental conditions and yet service only a single device into the future. He can also minimise the wall acne that will often occur if multiple devices are required. The systems integrator, meanwhile, has the ab
ility now to provide much more sophisticated control strategies at a lower total installed cost with fewer devices to install and service in the building.
Today’s sensing devices are providing much better aesthetics and greater functionality for a relatively low, and, in the case of wireless, significantly lower, total installed cost. These devices are capable of providing a better picture of the true building conditions over a long term in smaller, more pleasing to the eye packages. The result is the creation of a broader market opportunity for control systems specifiers and installers and, ultimately, the potential for more energy efficient buildings and reduced carbon emissions for all.
Thinking Buildings Universe
Knowing where we can go to access particular information is something that can save us incalculable amounts of valuable time. The new Thinking Buildings Universe from Grundfos now offers building services professionals a centralised information point that is a one stop shop for commercial buildings services pump applications.
This site has been specifically designed to work as an aide during planning and specification phases as well as when the selections have been made and the systems are operational. It has been developed with potential users around Europe who gave their input as to what they expected, needed and wanted to see from such an information hub.
One particularly useful tool is the Lexicon function that provides you with a glossary of pump industry terms. When you enter the website you will see the Lexicon option along the top bar which allows you to search for terms either by putting in a key word or by selecting from the A to Z option.
With this facility and so much more why not save this site as a ‘favourite’ so that your personal information centre will be available whenever you need it.